Why All Online Therapy Platforms Are Not Created Equal

Amanda Feinberg, LMFT, EMDR on Apr 19, 2023 in Mood and Feelings

Online therapy has been gaining popularity over the years, especially in light of the COVID-19 pandemic. While it may seem like all online therapy platforms are the same, the reality is that they are not.

Let’s take a look at the three main benefits and disadvantages of insurance-based online therapy vs. cash-pay online therapy.

Benefits of Insurance-Based Online Therapy

  • Lower cost: One of the biggest benefits of insurance-based online therapy is the lower cost. Insurance-based therapy usually has a lower out-of-pocket cost for patients, making it more accessible to a wider range of individuals.
  • Convenience: Insurance-based online therapy is more convenient since the patient does not have to worry about submitting insurance claims or finding an out-of-network therapist.
  • Volume of therapists: Insurance-based therapy offers patients a variety of therapists to choose from, making it easier to find a therapist quickly.

Disadvantages of Insurance-Based Online Therapy

  • Quality of care: In-network therapists may be more focused on meeting insurance company requirements than on providing high-quality care. They may be limited in terms of the amount of time they can spend with patients, the type of treatment they can provide, or the number of sessions they can offer. This can impact the quality of care that patients receive and may limit their ability to make meaningful progress in their treatment.

Lack of personalization: Patients who choose insurance-based online therapy may not have access to therapists who have specialized training or extensive experience in treating their specific mental health concerns. In some cases, insurance plans may only cover therapists who have a minimum level of education or experience, which may not be sufficient to provide the level of care that some patients need.

Less control over treatment: Insurance-based therapy may require prior authorization for certain treatments, which can limit a patient's control over their treatment plan. Patients may not be able to access the treatments they need because their insurance company does not cover them or because they require prior authorization.

Benefits of Cash-Pay Online Therapy

  • Higher quality care: Cash-pay therapists often have smaller caseloads, which allows them to provide more personalized attention to each patient. They also have the freedom to use more innovative and effective therapy techniques, which may not be covered by insurance-based therapy.
  • Experience and qualifications: Cash-pay online therapists often have more experience and qualifications than insurance-based online therapists. This is because they have chosen to forego the limitations and paperwork of insurance-based therapy, allowing them to focus solely on providing quality mental health care to their patients.
  • Reduced stigma: Cash-pay online therapy can reduce the stigma associated with seeking mental health treatment. Patients don't have to worry about their employer or insurance company finding out about their therapy sessions and can seek treatment without fear of discrimination or prejudice.

Disadvantages of Cash-Pay Online Therapy

  • Cost: One of the biggest disadvantages of cash-pay therapy is the cost. Out-of-network therapists typically charge higher fees than in-network therapists. This can make therapy more expensive and may not be feasible for patients who are on a tight budget.
  • Limited insurance coverage: Patients who choose cash-pay therapy may have limited insurance coverage. Insurance plans may not cover out-of-network therapy or may only cover a portion of the cost. This can make it difficult for patients to afford the care they need and may limit their ability to access treatment.
  • Limited availability: Cash-pay therapists may not be as widely available as in-network therapists. Patients may need to do more research in order to find a therapist who meets their needs.

One of the main advantages of out-of-network online therapists is the increased level of experience and qualifications they bring to the table. Cash-pay online therapists are not beholden to the constraints of insurance networks, which often prioritize cost-cutting over the quality of care. By choosing an out-of-network provider, clients can access therapists with more specialized training and expertise, resulting in a higher level of mental health care.

At MindVibe, we understand that the quality of mental health care is paramount, whether in-person or online. That's why we offer both online and in-person therapy sessions, allowing our clients the flexibility to choose what works best for them.

For some therapy treatments such as EMDR, in-person therapy will be more effective than online therapy. For some patients, having the ability to schedule an in-person therapy session for difficult weeks or when they experience a higher degree of trauma, anxiety, or depression is a great alternative to online therapy for more intensive therapy sessions. We believe in giving choice to the consumer so that they can choose online or in-person therapy sessions when it makes sense for them.

Amanda Feinberg is a Licensed Marriage & Family Therapist in Los Angeles, CA.

Recommended Articles